a Port Hope Simpson historical trail

Now then, as one thing has led on to the next, for those of you who enjoy delving into the past whilst enjoying present moments, why not for example, try and discover the truth behind Port Hope Simpson’s history of development?

Here are some facts and questions to maybe get you started.

I hope you will find them interesting.

But be warned!

It is a difficult trail to follow and hot in places!

It will test you to the limits of your endurance and

there will be no turning back!

It is not the place for the faint hearted!

Now is the time to back out if you have any doubts because I believe once you are bitten that’s it for life!

OK, are you still up for it? Right, let’s get going!

1.      First of all, look out for the incongruous looking tombstone near the brow of the hill adjacent to Pioneer Street. It marks the spot where Mr. Arthur Eric Williams, a Welshman and Miss Erica Anitoff Williams his four and a half year old daughter, died in tragic or possibly other circumstances in the early hours of 2 February 1940. What was the cause of deaths?

Arthur Eric and Erica were the eldest son and granddaughter of Mr. John Osborne Williams who was the owner of the Labrador Development Company Limited. It was his industrial operation that led to the first permanent settlement of,

Port Hope Simpson-the first Company Town in Labrador on 23 August 1934

2.    Find out who was married to Miss Olga Marie Agnes D’Anitoff, a White Russian and daughter of Count Vladimir D’Anitoff of Independent Means. What part did she play in the story? Whereabouts was her house situated in the town?

3.    What became of her?

4.    Why do you think Erica’s age of 18 months as engraved on her tombstone is incorrect? According to her birth certificate she was 43 months and two days when she died.

5.    What type of person would make such a mistake about what was written on his eldest son and his own grand-daughter’s grave? Don’t forget to keep detailed notes as you walk around! You never know what may be important.

6.                What happened to Mr. Keith Yonge, who originally came from London, England and was the Company’s Manager in Port Hope Simpson? Can you find out anything else about him? Is he still alive?

7.                What part did he play in the story?

8.                What were the consequences of “The Keith Yonge Contract” drawn up between Arthur Eric Williams and Keith Yonge in 1939? For example for one thing, it meant that Keith Yonge was contracted to cut wood for the Company on his own behalf whilst still employed as the Company’s manager. Do any of the local senior citizens remember anything? Discover in what other ways the contract was significant?

9.                Why was Mr. Yonge’s application to enlist in the British Army turned down?

10.            It is believed he decided to become a Moravian Minister. Did that happen?

11.             What became of him?

12.                        Why did the British Government decide to classify as secret the Public Enquiry in 1945 into The Affairs of the Labrador Development Company at Port Hope Simpson until 1996?

13.                        Were they mistaken when they entered into a business relationship with Mr. J.O. Williams? What other evidence of early industrial development in the town can you find? When were Bowaters there? What did they leave behind for the good of everybody?

14.                        Why was the permanent residential address of Mr. John Osbourne and Mrs. Ethel Kate Williams: “14 Dunraven House, Cardiff, Wales” not included in the epitaph on the tombstone?

15.                        Why were the words with the “not quite right” feel to them, “Labrador House, Southerndown, Wales” included instead?

16.                        Was somebody still out to deceive and/or hide something from the local people even after the deaths?

17.            Why hadn’t the local people been able to find out what had been going on behind the scenes?

18.            Dunraven Bay” in Wales was associated with smuggling. Guess why “Dunraven” was not included on the tombstone!

19.                        Why were the words “Having saved his wife he died in the flames with his daughter Erica” engraved on the first simple headstone but left out from the final epitaph? See the first headstone for yourself. It was still there when I looked in July last year.

20.          An incorrect address was entered for Erica’s place of birth on her birth certificate and for her father’s place of permanent residence when she was born. The house they should have been living in had not even been built at the time! Was this more deliberate deception?

21.            If so, why?

22.          Were certain people trying to hide their real plush addresses?

23.                      A building with the nameplate “Labrador” still stands at Ogmore-by-Sea, Bridgend, Wales to this day. It was built according to its current owner, by a man who made his money in Labrador. Does this imply anything about the ambitions of Mr. J.O. Williams?

24.                      Find out how and why Sir John Hope Simpson, a 66 year old retired Indian civil servant, Newfoundland Commissioner of Natural Resources and self-appointed Acting-Commissioner of Justice from 1934-36 gave the town his name. The christening as he later described it, left The Dominions Office and the British Government with egg-all-over-their-faces and wide-open to accusations of favouritism. He claimed it had been at the Company’s request he had named the site of its headquarters “Hope Simpson.”[1][1] Was it right that an English civil servant and the Dominions Office should have allowed such a thing to happen?

25.                      What good did Mr. J.O. Williams and Sir John Hope Simpson do for the people of Port Hope Simpson?

26.                      What lasting effect did the relationship between Mr. J. O. Williams and the Dominion of Government have upon economic progress, living conditions and the welfare of the Port Hope Simpson folk?

27.          How have the Provincial and the Federal Governments helped economic progress in the area after Confederation in 1949?

28.                      Did Sir John Hope Simpson purchase timber rights in Labrador on his own behalf?

29.          Mr. J. O. Williams borrowed money for the written purpose of building 400 houses at Port Hope Simpson whilst Sir John Hope Simpson facilitated the release of loans at British tax-payers expense from the Colonial Fund in London. At the very most, only 16 houses were ever built and very low wages were paid to the loggers and their families whilst the Company Store kept them in a vicious circle of debt and poverty. Why was this state of affairs allowed to continue?

30.                      Discover more for yourself about the reality of life for the early settlers in Port Hope Simpson. Discover for yourself what wages and living conditions were really like from 1934 onwards. Find out more about how the Company’s store was operated and its effect upon the local people. Where was it located in the Town?

31.                        Why did Sir John Hope Simpson instruct that the Gordon Bradley’s Report into working conditions in the forests be suppressed?

32.          Find out who had the family nickname of “Jack the Lad”

33.                      Discover why the civil service and the practioners of private enterprise show up so badly from 1934 - 49.

34.          Read what Mr. Thomas Lodge had to say in his book, “Dictatorship in Newfoundland[2][2]

35.                      Look out for the ruins of the Company’s sawmill and see two preserved Company houses of the hundreds more that were supposed to be built. Visit the town’s Learning Centre to see copies of the original correspondence to do with The Public Enquiry that was held into the Affairs of the Labrador Development Company Limited in 1945. See many other original historical artefacts from the area.

36.                      Why was Sir John Hope Simpson so obsessive about keeping his Newfoundland Rangers under the authority of Natural Resources instead of under their more natural home of the Department of Justice?

37.          Find out why Mr. Arthur Eric Williams was sent out by his father to Port Hope Simpson in 1939? Personally, I remain convinced Eric died for the sins of his father so to speak and it's quite likely that Erica died unintentionally.

38.                      Was there a Cover-Up going on and is it still going on today?

39.                      What was the relationship like between the loggers and their families and the Company’s owners?

40.                      Why did the Dominions Office in London change its attitude towards Mr. J.O. Williams so soon after his first logging camp was set-up in Port Hope Simpson, 1934?

41.                        What was the real thinking behind setting-up The Public Enquiry in St. John’s that reported in 1945, into the affairs of the Labrador Development Company Limited?

42.          Why was Mr. Thomas Lodge, formerly Newfoundland Commissioner for Public Utilities who was effectively removed from office in disgrace, appointed to the Board of the Labrador Development Company Limited in 1940?

43.          Why was Mr. Claude Fraser, secretary to the Department of Natural Resources including the office of Sir John Hope Simpson, ordered to the post of Government Director of the Company on 2 February 1940? On exactly the same day that Eric and Erica Williams died?

44.          My personal opinion is that I think the real truth is still being covered - up by people who are still alive today.

45.          Is it an accurate and fair description to describe Mr. J.O. Williams and his employees as “The Williams Boom or Bust, Smash and Grab Gang” that hit Town from 1934 – 40 leaving a hoary reputation as their only real legacy?

Good luck!

All the best

Ernie Pritchard

03.01.2004

 

Source: Pritchard E.R.L. Tombstone-a history of development in Port Hope Simpson; unpublished manuscript 2003

 

 

 

 



 



[1][1] Neary P. “White Tie and Decorations Sir John and Lady Hope Simpson in Newfoundland 1934-1936” p12 1996 University of Toronto Press

[2][2] Lodge T. “Dictatorship in Newfoundland”, Commissioner for Public Utilities in Newfoundland 1934-1937 1939 Cassell & Company Limited